Talk about a shocker. I guess the best man/woman doesn't always win. It all depends on how many teenboppers you have voting for you!

 

10-4 on the shocker, Well you never know whats going to happen.

 

Yea, just lost my interest and faith in American Idol, and a lot of it started with Sanjaya. A few of the good ones went before he did. Melinda has the best voice, plus I think she will be more successful than the two that are left after the show goes off this year.

 

oooooooooh no, you just RUINED MY EVENING... I never look ahead and I'm in PACIFIC TIME ZONE! Whhaaaaaaaa.....

 

Me too. I had just started the show on my DVR when this was posted!!!!

 

I guess I am a young one on here, personally I am all for Blake...I thought his version of 'You Give Love A Bad Name' by Bon Jovi was AMAZING!!! But I am also a big hip hop fan...Melinda was very BORING to me, I would never listen to anything she records. I guess it is all about personal taste. I agree she was a GREAT singer, just BORING!

 

He ruined that song! I guess I'm too old! Thats alright from last years show Chris daughtry was the best and so far he is the most successfull. Melinda will be the same way. So far the winner is most of the time overshadowed by one of the other ones who doesn't win. Exception would be Kelly Clarkson.

 

I think Melinda is the best singer of the group.. however, THAT alone doesn't sell records... there has to be some charisma there and both Jordan and Blake have that, they have a 'hook' that will sell records.

I'm sure Melinda can sell records too however, there are lots of great singers out there. Being memorable will sell more records than being the best singer... she bang she bang...

 

Who'll ever forget William Hung!!

 

This show is still on Make it stop pleaseeeeee