suspension damage help
01-23-2017, 11:50 AM
#1
suspension damage help
Hi, very new to this forum. I just recently wrecked my car on some ice and need some tips on where to start repairing it.
Took it to my mechanic to have it looked over and they claim i need
they also listed an alignment, brake pads/rotors, and tires. I'd like to fix this my self, but i'm not much of a mechanic. Is there anywhere I need to start first because I'm going to be doing this little by little. Are there certain brand name parts to get? special tools? should i have just left this up to the professional? or is it too far gone to be repaired?
Any information helps.
Thanks.
Took it to my mechanic to have it looked over and they claim i need
- sway bar links/ bushings
- right front axle shaft bent
- right front lower control arm and left front lower control arm bent
- right front strut
- right front spindle
they also listed an alignment, brake pads/rotors, and tires. I'd like to fix this my self, but i'm not much of a mechanic. Is there anywhere I need to start first because I'm going to be doing this little by little. Are there certain brand name parts to get? special tools? should i have just left this up to the professional? or is it too far gone to be repaired?
Any information helps.
Thanks.
Last edited by 843de; 01-25-2017 at 08:21 AM. Reason: Changed "break" to "brake"...just one of those things that causes me to go goofy
01-23-2017, 12:01 PM
#2
Platinum Member
Join Date: 12-06-2009
Location: Alabama
Posts: 11,130
Posting the year, model and condition would help us tell you if it's worth repairing.
If you're "not much of a mechanic" as you stated, it's best left up to a pro. That list you showed is just what they can see. Once the work starts, there will be more parts found that need replacement.
You also said you took it to your mechanic. How ? Sure hope you didn't drive it there with that many damaged parts. I would advise getting a collision repair shop to look at it. That's what they do and see every day.
If you're "not much of a mechanic" as you stated, it's best left up to a pro. That list you showed is just what they can see. Once the work starts, there will be more parts found that need replacement.
You also said you took it to your mechanic. How ? Sure hope you didn't drive it there with that many damaged parts. I would advise getting a collision repair shop to look at it. That's what they do and see every day.
01-23-2017, 12:56 PM
#3
Posting the year, model and condition would help us tell you if it's worth repairing.
If you're "not much of a mechanic" as you stated, it's best left up to a pro. That list you showed is just what they can see. Once the work starts, there will be more parts found that need replacement.
You also said you took it to your mechanic. How ? Sure hope you didn't drive it there with that many damaged parts. I would advise getting a collision repair shop to look at it. That's what they do and see every day.
If you're "not much of a mechanic" as you stated, it's best left up to a pro. That list you showed is just what they can see. Once the work starts, there will be more parts found that need replacement.
You also said you took it to your mechanic. How ? Sure hope you didn't drive it there with that many damaged parts. I would advise getting a collision repair shop to look at it. That's what they do and see every day.
And honestly I want to try and start learning how to fix my own vehicles, I know bits and pieces but the best way to learn is hands on.
01-23-2017, 01:04 PM
#4
Platinum Member
Join Date: 04-09-2006
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
Posts: 7,033
x2 what Firemangeorge said. That is some major mechanical damage there. That isn't a project to start learning how to do your own repairs on.
What kind of $'s did they estimate at the first shop?
What kind of $'s did they estimate at the first shop?
01-23-2017, 01:11 PM
#5
my friends did say they could help me with the sway bar and control arms. Could I possibly have the mechanic do harder stuff or would it be best to get it all done at once?
01-23-2017, 01:52 PM
#6
Platinum Member
Join Date: 04-09-2006
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
Posts: 7,033
That's your choice - either way works. Working on it yourself will require a mess of tools, primarily metric sockets and wrenches, as well as a large torque wrench, and a suitable and safe method of raising the car up so you can work underneath it.
A number of the items you say need replacement are covered here fairly well in the "How-To" section (axle shaft, Lower control arms, struts, sway bar links and bushings, brake pads/rotors).
What I would worry about though is hidden damage considering that the lower control arms are bent, the axle is a write-off, and the strut is damaged. That kind of damage is not necessarily blatently visible - Firemangeorge's suggestion about taking it to a collision shop is a good one. I'd hate to pour a mess of $'s into it, and end up finding you have a twisted unibody that will cost major $'s to fix - if it IS fixable.
A number of the items you say need replacement are covered here fairly well in the "How-To" section (axle shaft, Lower control arms, struts, sway bar links and bushings, brake pads/rotors).
What I would worry about though is hidden damage considering that the lower control arms are bent, the axle is a write-off, and the strut is damaged. That kind of damage is not necessarily blatently visible - Firemangeorge's suggestion about taking it to a collision shop is a good one. I'd hate to pour a mess of $'s into it, and end up finding you have a twisted unibody that will cost major $'s to fix - if it IS fixable.
01-23-2017, 02:08 PM
#7
Platinum Member
Join Date: 12-06-2009
Location: Alabama
Posts: 11,130
With that amount of damage, I would be worried about the hidden damage as whopper stated.
Unibody damage and a possible bent engine cradle are 2 real possibilities. A bent axle could have very easily damaged the transmission.
Fwiw. I used to work at a large shop that did mechanical repairs and body work. 2 separate shops under one roof. I've seen many hidden damaged parts show up after the work was started.
A 9 year old fair condition car with that many miles may not be worth what it will take to fix it.
Not trying to scare you. Just stating what you may be in for.
Unibody damage and a possible bent engine cradle are 2 real possibilities. A bent axle could have very easily damaged the transmission.
Fwiw. I used to work at a large shop that did mechanical repairs and body work. 2 separate shops under one roof. I've seen many hidden damaged parts show up after the work was started.
A 9 year old fair condition car with that many miles may not be worth what it will take to fix it.
Not trying to scare you. Just stating what you may be in for.
01-23-2017, 02:17 PM
#8
Moderator
Join Date: 01-23-2009
Location: Fredericksburg,VA
Posts: 24,803
The estimate would have to include the alignment if they are going to replace a spindle/knuckle, both LCAs, a strut (I would recommend you spring for the other).
I don't think anything you listed except the alignment is a pro job. Mostly bolt on stuff, you would need to rent some proper tools and learn how to use a torque wrench and follow directions.
The upside is you can take the insurance money for labor and put it in your pocket.
I don't think anything you listed except the alignment is a pro job. Mostly bolt on stuff, you would need to rent some proper tools and learn how to use a torque wrench and follow directions.
The upside is you can take the insurance money for labor and put it in your pocket.
01-23-2017, 02:20 PM
#9
The estimate would have to include the alignment if they are going to replace a spindle/knuckle, both LCAs, a strut (I would recommend you spring for the other).
I don't think anything you listed except the alignment is a pro job. Mostly bolt on stuff, you would need to rent some proper tools and learn how to use a torque wrench and follow directions.
The upside is you can take the insurance money for labor and put it in your pocket.
I don't think anything you listed except the alignment is a pro job. Mostly bolt on stuff, you would need to rent some proper tools and learn how to use a torque wrench and follow directions.
The upside is you can take the insurance money for labor and put it in your pocket.
Sadly I won't be getting money out of insurance due to the fact I was trying to be a cheap ass.
01-23-2017, 02:26 PM
#10
With that amount of damage, I would be worried about the hidden damage as whopper stated.
Unibody damage and a possible bent engine cradle are 2 real possibilities. A bent axle could have very easily damaged the transmission.
Fwiw. I used to work at a large shop that did mechanical repairs and body work. 2 separate shops under one roof. I've seen many hidden damaged parts show up after the work was started.
A 9 year old fair condition car with that many miles may not be worth what it will take to fix it.
Not trying to scare you. Just stating what you may be in for.
Unibody damage and a possible bent engine cradle are 2 real possibilities. A bent axle could have very easily damaged the transmission.
Fwiw. I used to work at a large shop that did mechanical repairs and body work. 2 separate shops under one roof. I've seen many hidden damaged parts show up after the work was started.
A 9 year old fair condition car with that many miles may not be worth what it will take to fix it.
Not trying to scare you. Just stating what you may be in for.
What would I have to look for to notice the hidden damage? Or is it just something is have to find out after I pieced it back together?