Try general Exclaim UHP for around $90 just not great in the snow. I have some on my Charger and they have been great.

 

I replaced my 215/55/16 Affinity's with 205/60/16 Assurance Comfortreds and am very impressed. The narrower tire is better in the snow, and by going to an "H" rated tire, I got better sidewall stiffness so I did actually notice slightly improved driveability. Also, a much nicer ride and quieter. If I were driving it, I would have installed Exalto's.

My wife uses it for work, so her issues were comfort and ride quality. Plus, the 80k warranty helps, and the 205 was about $20 per tire less than the 215.