I'm also 23, and also paying about $143 a month. Never had an accident, but I do have a couple of tickets on my record. I'm going through State Farm as well.

 

Im 19 with one accident on record when I was 16. I pay $1100 every six months for insurance on the SS. Thats after it dropped last time I paid it. But its worth it to me.

 

I am 25 (just hit the big 25 on 3/24) and pay I believe $46/ month. The reason I believe that is the number is because I pay a total of $76/ month for both cars and if I remember correctly my '99 cavalier was $30/month for liability. I pay out the entire 6 months at one time and the last time I payed it went down from $80/month to $76/month. Hopefully the next time it comes to pay, hopefully it will go down again now that I am 25.

I have a $500 deductable and go through Allied insurance. I also have my renters through them, and have good drivers record.

I was suprised when I called and the insurance was less then $10/ month more for the SS over an LS.

 

According to my insurance agent with MetLife, the HHR has a decent record with Ins.
companies in general mostly due to the fact that it is not that popular with the younger generation. Therefore, it has been cheaper to insure.

My 2010 only cost me $37 a year more then my old 2002 Focus did.
Now, if the monster blaster group ever discovers how many oversized sub-woofers you can cram into the cargo area of the HHR, we may pay the price in the future however, since this is the last year for HHR, that too may never happen.

Too bad GM is letting it go, I have only had it about a month and a half but so far, seems to be a decent ride.

 

I'm 25 I pay 86 a month for my 08 SS but I have the extra side air bags so that helped lower the price a little

 

I pay $436.13 a year, full agreed value $25k, $100 deductible, towing and parts coverage. I've got it insured as a collectable as I don't put a lot of miles(policy limit 5k per year) on it and have another car as a main vehicle.